Johnny Pizza

Discover Johnny Pizza in Durango, CO, offering delicious NY-style pizza with thin crust, garlicky sauce, and a welcoming atmosphere. Order online or visit our convenient location at 123 CO-172. Enjoy great food and friendly service today!

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Johnny Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Johnny Pizza
Johnny Pizza
Johnny Pizza
Johnny Pizza

Located at 123 CO-172 in the beautiful Durango, Colorado, Johnny Pizza serves up a slice of New York right in your hometown. Bursting with flavor, their thin crust pizzas and garlicky sauce please even the most discerning palates. Whether it’s a busy weekday or a relaxed weekend, you'll find a welcoming atmosphere that invites everyone to indulge in a meal with friends or family. With convenient online ordering, Johnny Pizza brings the taste of authentic pizza within reach, perfect for your on-the-go lifestyle. Make sure to grab a slice or two and experience Durango's beloved pizza spot that captures the essence of community dining.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

123 CO-172, Durango, CO 81303, United States

Phone

+1 970-247-4933

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Johnny Pizza
Johnny Pizza
Johnny Pizza
Johnny Pizza

This local gem has become a cornerstone of the Durango food scene, offering delicious specialties that turn ordinary meals into extraordinary experiences. Johnny Pizza's story started with a simple passion for pizza-making, a craft refined over the years to deliver what many consider the best NY-style pizza in the area. Each pizza is crafted with precision and care, ensuring a quality that exceeds expectations every single time.

Residents rave about the flavor profiles and generous portions, making this establishment a go-to for pizza lovers. The diverse menu includes not only pizzas but also a variety of Mexican dishes, providing diners with plenty of options to satisfy any hunger. Families often visit Johnny Pizza to feast on the popular Supreme pizza or dive into the rich, savory flavors of the Pozole for a change of pace.

Staff members take pride in the warm, friendly service, ensuring that every guest feels welcomed and appreciated. The restaurant's consistent popularity speaks volumes, especially during busy hours such as Thursday at 7 AM when the restaurant reaches full capacity. Johnny Pizza's dedication to quality yields repeat customers who come back for their favorite dishes week after week.

Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or just stopping by for a slice, Johnny Pizza guarantees satisfaction with every visit. With local ingredients and a commitment to quality, this pizza haven embodies the spirit of community dining.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday7 AM-7 PM
  • Monday6 AM-8 PM
  • Tuesday6 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday6 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday6 AM-8 PM
  • Friday6 AM-8 PM
  • Saturday6 AM-8 PM

Johnny Pizza stands out with its specialty pizzas like the Meat Lovers and Johnny's Demon, which draw locals and visitors alike for their unique flavors. The menu boasts a delightful Mexican section too, offering rolled tacos and enchiladas that cater to various cravings. The restaurant's thin crust is a crowd favorite, complemented by their signature garlicky sauce that's simply irresistible. Johnny Pizza accommodates busy schedules by providing online ordering, making it easy to enjoy a delicious meal without the wait. The casual yet inviting vibe makes it a great spot for friends to gather and share good eats. Plus, with a convenience store location, picking up a meal is a breeze, keeping that local charm alive.

Johnny Pizza

The exterior of Johnny Pizza captures the essence of Durango with its charming store-front that serves as a beacon for pizza lovers. Its welcoming entrance invites customers in, making it a favorite stop whether it's for dine-in or takeout. The outdoor seating area offers a casual vibe for those who prefer to enjoy their pizzas al fresco, especially during the warmer months when the surrounding scenery enhances the dining experience. Light pours through the windows, creating a cheerful environment that reflects the energy of the community.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Do not be fooled; this is real pizza! And it has absolutely no business being as good as it is in a dang gas station. If you look in the kitchen you can see they make the dough fresh, and I'm betting as a pizza boy myself that the sauce and cheese are made/grated fresh as well. My only criticism: it could've been cooked a bit harder, but my broiler fixed that. 10/10 probably the best in the area

J
Jrbnrbr

Best pizza in Durango and it's in a convenience store. Big NY style pieces. The crust got the crunch. Edit: our family is leaving the area. For two plus years this has been my families go to for pizza night. Never fails. Thanks y'all!

D
Dan J.

This is legit good pizza. Sauce is very garlicky which I like. I dropped this pizza in my front seat taking it out of my car so I'm sure it looked at lot better beforehand. Fresh jalapenos is a great touch. This Is better pizza than I ever expected to get out of a convenient store and maybe the best pizza in Durango.

Z
Zane P.

Wow, definitely surprised by the taste, as ex NY'r myself I have high standard for pizza. As a recent transplant to Durango I find mostly all restaurants seem to mainly sell Burgers or Pizza, and thus far only have tried a few breweries and HOMESLICE (not bad pizza, but bonus points for dog friendly). Finally got around to trying Johnny's Pizza which is tucked inside the Roadhouse Deli south of Elmore's Corner and they really are cooking up a great pie. I ordered online and for safety chose the crisp option which I definitely enjoyed, maybe I will try regular next time. But overall flavor was first to appreciate, texture of crust and bottom where a strong 8 out of 10, but the subtle hints of garlic in the red sauce is really the memorable part. Definitely will be back to try other items on the menu. Ps they have a deli case that sells pre-sliced and wrapped desserts, not sure if made in house or not? but if so, any place selling homemade Cannoli's is legit.

J
Jason S.

This is my kind of place, off the beaten path & looks like it's straight out of New York. The sauce was nice garlicky & savory. Crust done to a beautiful crisp. I've tried over 40 different pizza joints across the USA and this right here is in the top 10.

T
Tyler

Great NY style pizza. I have lived in several states from the Rocky Mountain West to New England including the Deep South, this is now one of my favorites NY style pizza restaurants.

R
Russell O.